Episode 2: "This is very uncomfortable now."

Posted by Professor Chan on January 15th, 2009 at 2:35 AM
Share:

Remember the one or two good things I said about the Idol season premier?  Well, I take it all back.  It was mostly terrible for an unnecessary two hours of bad singing, and I'm talking about the Gold Ticket winners.

This nearly interminable episode showcased everything that's bad about Idol.  Two hours of tedious bad singing, mocking of the mentally handicapped.  More bad singing.  And then just to rub it in they show us a teaser for "The Most Dramatic Hollywood Week Ever."  Which is still nearly a month away.  Man, that looked really good, and featured pretty much everybody we've seen get a ticket so far.  
------

Thankfully we've got plenty of Worster talent to choose from tonight.  It's as if they let all of the water out of the Idol talent pool by season 8, and this is the crap that was left floating in puddles at the bottom.  Trust me, it's the only thing getting me through this recap.

Here's my stream-lined recap of the highlights and lowlights.  Mostly lowlights.  Okay, nearly entirely lowlights.

1. Blond girl that was bad, but in a boring way.  Next.

2. Ashley -- sucks up to Simon by singing a song he "wrote."  She even screwed up the lyrics from the chorus and they let her through.  I'll be surprised if we ever hear from her again.

3. Casey from KC -- McPhee look-a-like.  Decent singer.  Kara says "I see a package here."  What?  Casey is a dude?  First penis/transvestite joke of the season.  YES!

4. Opera Brian.  Dressed like a pro wrestler.  Not terrible enough to be funny.  Next.

5. Montage of bad singers.  Blah.  A montage of failed contestants crying.  This is not funny at all -- okay, the one girl with Fraggle hair screeching "no" over and over was pretty funny.

6. Von The Tool With The Stupid Hat -- Talks about his "strange range... for a guy."  Von does some wacky hijinx which gets me excited that he's a Worster.  Sings "Over The Rainbow."  So he's a Friend of Dorothy.  Good so far.  Has a loud voice, and he's a spazz.  Excellent.  They leave us hanging for a commercial...  And with the recap of his goofy, spastic dancing I'm already sick of Von's act.  He might suck really bad in Hollywood, though, so fingers crossed.

7. Michael Castro -- Jason's lesser talented and even dumber brother.  Seriously, between the two of them they're scratching mid-50s IQ-wise.  We waste what seems like an hour with Los Bros Castro.  Michael has a horrible pink Flock of Seagulls swoop haircut, so terrible hair clearly runs in the family.  Michael says he started singing 20 days before audition.  His voice is  really nasally, just like his brother.  Now I've wasted about an hour talking about this guy.  Goes to Hollywood, but his magic journey ends there.

8. Bald Matt -- He's an even uglier Daughtry.  But you know, less talented.  He's bald, he has a beard, he has a wife and daughter that he's singing for, and he's a welder.  He's just one humongous back tattoo of his name away from actually BEING Daughtry.  Bald Matt's singing is mediocre with moments of goodness.  He's a troll, so I like him, but then he flushes it all away by crying.  What a nancy-boy.

9. Jazz-min.  Pink hair, stupid hat, yellow teeth.  Not terrible enough to extrapolate further.

However, while we're on the subject of bad teeth, what the hell is wrong with the orthodontics industry in Kansas City?  I've seen more fangs on the contestants than on an entire season of "When Animals Attack."

10. Creepy Wrestling Screamer Girl is back, briefly.

11. Lisa Loeb Girl from Wamego, Kansas (I love that town name.)  She's decent, she's over the top with her power ballad growling, but I see VFTW possibilities.  So we'll probably never see her again.

12. Tag Team Asia and India/Rapping Duo.  One is very large, and the other can sing, beatbox and breakdance.  Whoo-hoo, a black, female Blake Lewis with a gigantic sister.  Okay, Asia/India girl has possibilities.

13. Tag Team Effeminate Bro-mates Jamar and Danny.  Jamar makes funny faces and has a pathetic one-inch fauxhawk.  His singing is barely passable for a Gold Ticket, so there is definitely VFTW possibilities.
Danny, who I officially dub "Knuckle Punch" Danny is a music teacher who can actually sing.  A rarity for Idol.  In fact he comes prepared with a sob story and dodgy facial hair.  Knuckle Punch Danny is in it to win it.

14. Montage of terrible girl singers.  Boo, I want to hear more from SnaggleTooth Girl.  I'm gonna study really hard to be a dentist and then move to Kansas City and become a millionaire.  Seriously.

15.  Anoop Dawg -- Hopefully he can work some Sanjaya magic.  He's certainly got the eyebrows, and he's entertaining.  The only funny moment of the night comes when pea-brained Simon gets stuck on the fact that Anoop's Master's Thesis in American Folklore was an essay on barbecues.  After repeating his non-joke Anoop gives Simon a "sure, whatever you say, dude" dismissal.  I like Anoop.  He sings passably well, giving us hope that he can sneak into the finals.  VFTW contender.

16. Horrible cheerleaders lead us into Andrew the ambiguously gay ice cream server.   He sings in a cheesy over the top style.  His second song is so bad Randy actually changes his 'yes' vote to a 'no.'  That was amusing.  Randy is an imbecile for even saying 'yes' in the first place.

17. Band Leader Asa -- A perky black guy who sings a Michael Jackson song decently.  Paula correctly points out that whenever an Idol sings Michael Jackson "it's usually a disaster."  Asa is overly enthusiastic and his daughter is nearly trampled during the Asa family celebration.  Asa is a VFTW contender.

18. Michael Nicewonder (no joke, that's his name.) -- a Forrest Gumpian guy with a frightful Lloyd Christmas blonde bowl cut.  Michael seems to be mentally challenged, so Simon tees off on the guy and makes him cry.  See, Simon loves to pick on the handicapped because it's easier.  He's the laziest guy making $30 mil in show business.

19. Backflip Dennis -- a kooky guy with bad teeth, bad dreadlocks, a Gumpian personality and a ton of exuberance.  He's over-excited and under-talented.  But he begs for about 20 minutes so they all give him a pity ticket to Hollywood.  I smell a VFTW Contender, baby.

20. Mia - Pink-haired and purple-lipped lady who gives a godawful Minnie Ripperton rendition and then a half-hearted "the judges suck, I'm a star" rant.  Seriously, is that the best they can do?  Even the delusional non-talents are half-assing it this year.

21. Lil Rounds -- All the Idol Pimpage for two hours and she turns out to be a less talented Fantasia clone.  Young daughter - check.  Sob story -- check.  Husband who couldn't care less that his wife is going to Hollywood... okay, that's a little different.  I kind of like Mr. Big Rounds and his complete lack of enthusiasm about being on Idol.  But I wasn't impressed with R&B diva Lil.  She's out of tune for half the song and the judges grossly heap on the B.S.-- I mean praise for about a week.  Then the show ends.  Yay.
-----
This was a punishing two hours.  Every commercial break I'd say some version of "Gadzooks, we still got an hour left of this crap?"  or "Holy crap, we still have 45 minutes of this crap?"

On the plus side, the expanded Hollywood week looks looks like a doozy (and takes about three weeks to play out.)

Well, only 8 more hours of this crap to go.  It'll be like watching Andy Warhol's movie "Empire."  But with less plot.
-----
Let's hear your thoughts on "The Most Talent-Packed Season Ever."  See, even their breathless hyperbole is half-assed and flaccid this year.

--Chan

__________________________

Professor Chan For Questions, Comments, Fan Mail -- 

vftwchan @ gmail.com


magicrob75
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 6:43am
Joined: 02 Apr 2008

just wanted to say that the new page layout blows!!

__________________________

Rob Jenkins-Comic/Actor
www.RobJenkinsMagic.com

manlambda
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 7:30am
Joined: 16 Apr 2008

Chan you are a better man than me. My partner went to bed early because he had to get up early. After about a half an hour of this crap I started wandering with my remote coming back for bits in pieces then quickly turning again. I think the Cash-hos did me in.

VoteOffThePlant
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 7:36am
Joined: 12 Mar 2008

Chan, great to see you're back. My mother passed away this summer, just after Idol was over, and your great blogs cheer me up.

Can we have a thread for Ashley ... she's the tall 20-yr-old girl from NJ (sound familiar?) right? I think she'll make top 24. Seems sweet and dumb enough for Simon to "keep her around," if you know what I mean.

popsavant
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 7:57am
Joined: 14 Jan 2009

According to the source of all knowledge, Wikipedia, Simon's writing credit for that song sounds like he just casually mentioned "Hey, there should be a song about footprints or something" over a pitcher of martinis one night.

Michael Castro, as I posted last night, looks like Andy Samberg in drag. Agree about the nasal voice... the Castros must be stopped now, and not the Fidel and Raul branch of the family.

Lisa Loeb girl was Jessica Furney... early front runner for my yearly Idol crush.

Daniel Gokey, the music teacher who lost is wife, can actually sing a little. More importantly, he's going to carry the MILF audience should we get to the voting rounds, since he's a walking Lifetime movie... voice, decent looking, sad story. Watch out for him.

Dennis (the charity vote guy) is gone by the next show.

No Idol Trainwreck Legends were born last night, unfortunately.

__________________________

http://popsavant.com

gaziza
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 10:15am
Joined: 13 Mar 2008

"I smell a VFTW Contender, baby."

It seemed like this episode was all VFTW contenders. Well... scratch that, our picks are generally entertaining in some way.

I actually liked Anoop Dawg though, you forgot to mention that Simon told him that his look was "all a bit geeky," that he looked like a "techie" and that he looked like he was from Silicon Valley. To me it looked like A Dawg was wearing a Hollister/American Eagle/A&F/whatever button down, cargo shorts and flip flops. I think the only reason Simon thought he looked like he worked in IT was because he was Indian. Put Anoop's gear on a white guy and it'd be "all a bit frat." For some reason Simon's comments about his appearance seemed to really say "Indian pop star? No."

I didn't see him looking down his nose at some of the other contestants ridiculous wardrobe decisions (case in point: newly widowered guy had some all-over-print Affliction t-shirt that looked stupid on him and made me think his buddy with the pube-hawk dressed him. See also: Von's hat.)

Professor Chan
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 11:59am
Joined: 10 Jan 2007

Thanks for the insightful comments gaziza.  And I'm glad I can amuse you VoteoffthePlant.  Just doing my community service.

Yeah, I forgot all of the racist undertones of Simon's comments.  I tuned Simon out because his jokes were bad.  You're right that what Anoop was wearing wasn't "nerdy" as much as frat boy casual.  I think wearing flip-flops to an audition is pretty unprofessional, but then again, this is Idol where freaks wear Bunny suits and horrid cheerleader outfits.  So yeah, Anoop looks like he's not really trying to jump on the Idol freak train, which is another reason to root for him.  That's probably why Simon didn't like him.  Oh and he's Asian.

--Chan 

__________________________

Professor Chan For Questions, Comments, Fan Mail -- 

vftwchan @ gmail.com

Jack MeHoff
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 12:27pm
Joined: 05 Mar 2008

Who was the contestant that Kara told "Had a nice instrument'? How would she know?

MojoPin66
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 12:55pm
Joined: 26 Feb 2008

Hi, Professor! So glad you're back.

Oh man, that little chick who was screaming her head off had me rolling. I bet that played out well for her between the ages of 2 and 12. Problem is, nobody ever told her to stop.

Castro's younger bro... Clearly as sharp as cotton candy. And yeah, the young cat needs to come down a notch or twelve. The attitude definitely doesn't match the talent. Kara called him "cocky". Understate much?

And wow, speaking of Kara and cock(y), I seriously have the hots for her. Damn...

Backflip Dennis... Typified your "a punishing two hours" statement. And they put him through! I actually agreed with Simon when he scolded the other judges, saying, "That's what you call getting duped."

__________________________

"I'm talking about, of course, cat juggling."

BeckEye
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 1:44pm
Joined: 20 Feb 2008

Happy to be reading your recaps again, and in the company of other people whose minds completely head for the gutter when they hear the word "package." Feels like home.

I can't believe these damn audition shows are 2 hours long. And I can't believe I've watched every minute of both of them so far.

__________________________

Idol recaps and inane pop culture ramblings - http://thepopeye.blogspot.com

allanm051
Posted: January 15, 2009 - 5:53pm
Joined: 15 Jan 2009

Hey, Chan, er, I mean Perfesser, I just read your latest and am I glad you are still blogging for VFTW. Otherwise, how would I ever know what happens on the show? I laughed out loud at some of your gags. Bikini girl has made all the google news headlines. I didn't believe it until I read your blog.

__________________________

Geezer Noir